Features In The Front Usability Get To The Back

Posted by uidesigner on Feb 15th, 2008 | 0 comments

Almost daily I face this this challenge. In fact it is infuriating about how many times in the day a usability concern is locked into the backseat. New features almost always seem to win versus making a new product better simply by improving the usability of an application.

Think of it like Jenga. In the game Jenga you must pull out the bottom blocks and place them on top. Every time you place a new block on top the structure becomes shakier and is unable to support the weight until it eventually all crumbles to the ground.

Imagine an application that is under this same pressure. You start out developing and have an Jenga Usability Disasterok UI that “seems” to support the weight of the tool and then you release the product to the consumers. They begin to complain of slow load times, confusing UI interactions. Back in the design room discussions are held about how to improve the usability. And the #1 thing brought up is add new features. No, No, No!

Take another look! You may not need to start from ground zero but, the foundation on which the application has been built is weak and trembling already and about to collapse. The last thing you should do is throw more weight on top of the impending disaster.

This is exactly what seems to have happened in more places then you can imagine. You eventually reach a point where the application looses it’s ability to scale to the increasing features. Sometimes you have to just close your eyes walk away and wait for the impending I told you so.

At this point you should be utilizing real user feedback, comments, and in house usability testing first hand to see what problems are plaguing the user. Sure some features that may be missing may be the culprit, but more often then not the tasks we perceived to be simple are way too complex and the base functionality of the application MUST be revisited to support future growth.

Kathy Sierra talks a lot about this in her blog.

I still have yet to find ways to counteract this line of thinking, but it’s just human nature – more is a perceived better. Any more ideas on how to combat this line of thinking?

Related articles:

  1. Corporate Conflicts A Cantakerous Cacophany of Confusion.
  2. Why Did My Design Fail Miserably and Other Not Nice Things?
  3. UI Design Lessons: Are You Driving Your Application Usability Off A Cliff?
  4. UI Design Challenge: A Table or Grid With Too Much Information
  5. Design Lessons: Should You Rush Your Design To Market or Stall it for Great Design?

Leave a Reply

comments-bottom

More UI Design Guide Articles

Why Did My Design Fail Miserably and Other Not Nice Things? So as I was laying here sick in bed and thinking about design stuff. That’s the great thing or a curse about having a design based job. Even while you are sick you can’t always turn off your brain. So unless asleep or staring at the tv you are always thinking. So the concept I was... Mar 28th, 2007 | no responses
thumbnail
Developing an Effective Corporate Social Community with Baby Steps – Part 1 So let’s talk a bit about effective corporate communities. Social network and social connectivity is all the rage. So much so that it has become the first “thing” some businesses look at when they build out an on line presence, or look to make changes to an existing one. The truth... Sep 16th, 2009 | no responses
SXSW 2009 – Has Begun! Well I arrived here after drivine 4 hours through some really crappy weather. Then I could not find parking close to the convention center, and then the line. The line was about 3 times longer than last year. I’m in the DAY stage cafe listening to the Author of Principles of Beautiful... Mar 13th, 2009 | no responses

Twitter is a great way to share new and exciting resources with all our viewers. Each day I provide links and commentary on all things UI. You can find UI resources, UI design examples, new techniques, and a lot more by Following @UIDESIGNGUIDE on Twitter.

The idea for this design blog first came about two years ago at SXSW Interactive.

Currently UI Design guide is in its fourth redesign. This site takes quite a bit of time to maintain as well as write the content. Just like UI Design this site is a passion that keeps evolving.

Inside, I cover articles on many topics icluding: lessons, prototyping methods, agile UX methods, design reviews, design challenges, application features, and of course design experiences, just to name a few.

With all the blogs out there you may be asking yourself who are you to give advice? That's a fair question. If you have a moment feel free to read about my design history.